Scottish Independence will affect whether North Northumbrians can find out what is happening across the Scottish Border on Regional Television news.

2nd January 2021

Dear Readers

If you live in a Northumberland community close to the Scottish Border, in towns like Cornhill on Tweed, Wooler and Otterburn, the now real possibility of Scotland breaking away from the United Kingdom and becoming a nation in its own right might not occur to you as something of real concern. However, with polls now showing a majority of Scots would vote to cut ties with the rest of Britain in a new Scottish Referendum on Independence, it is no longer an academic consideration: It could well happen in the next few years, particularly with the Scottish National Party riding high in Scottish polls- which suggest the Scottish National Party will get more than 50% of the vote in May 2021’s Holyrood Elections- enough for the Scottish Nationalists to get a landslide victory, especially as they are far ahead of the Scottish Tories (in second place and projected by recent polls to get just 20% of the vote in the Holyrood Elections).

So, the Scottish National Party, who are consistently agitating for a second Referendum on Independence because “Scotland has been dragged out of the European Union against her Will”, as so many Scottish Nationalists intone: If (as is likely) the Scottish National Party led by Nicola Sturgeon win big, they will strongly assert they have a very strong mandate to have that Referendum (less than seven years after Scotland narrowly voted “No!” to Independence in September 2014)- and the British Government will come under intense pressure to grant the Scottish administration based in Edinburgh their wish for what will likely be the second Independence Referendum in less than ten years. And given the current support for Scottish Independence the Scottish Nationalists have a high chance of winning.

So,you might think, what has this got to do with folk living in Northumberland watching the Regional News? Plenty, as it turns out because if Scotland breaks away from the United Kingdom the England- Scotland border will become a real national border between two separate countries. And since Britain has now left the European Union and the Scottish Nationalists dont like this, there is a fair chance that the Scottish Government will not only demand Northumbrians produce their passports if they wish to cross the Scottish Border to explore southern Scotland on a fine summer’s day, but that there may be visa requirements to visit Scotland too. There will also be Scottish Border check-points on the A68 at Carter Bar and on the A1 just north of Berwick upon Tweed, as well as on the Union Chain Bridge (rather an oxymoron after Scottish Independence!) at Horncliffe, just south-west of Berwick-upon-Tweed.

This will impact the Regional News service in the ITV Border (Scotland) and ITV Border (England) transmission area: It is almost certain that the Nationalist Scottish Government would ban ITV Border from transmitting news to homes in southern Scotland, certainly any relay transmitters on the Scottish side of the Border would be disabled and prevented from transmitting ITV Border (either English or Scottish versions) on Scottish Government instruction: This is because the Scottish Government (as led by the Scottish Nationalists) will deem ITV to be a British (or English) entity and, thus, unsuitable for Scotland. So ITV Border will have the population of its transmission area halved overnight, it would really just comprise ITV Border (England) which is produced for viewers in northern and central Cumbria along with the Haltwhistle area of south-west Northumberland. This means that ITV.Plc will deem its ITV Border region totally unviable and will likely merge what remains of it with the ITV Tyne Tees Television Region. That will lead to Cumbrians receiving mainly North-East based output (as with BBC Look North for the North East/ Cumbria).

For North Northumbrians, increased pressure on an extended ITV Tyne Tees Cumbria Regional News- service means higher pressure to cover Cumbria in news-output whilst North Northumbrians will end up even more neglected in any news-coverage than they are now. But this does not stop there.

Currently, viewers in northern Northumberland can get their televisions re-tuned, and get their Sky digi-box tweaked (with the help of a Sky technician) so that they can pick up ITV Border (Scotland)- which covers the Berwick-upon-Tweed area and southern Scotland in output if they wish. Thus, these viewers can currently watch ITV Border (Scotland) to find out what is going on just north of their community then switch to BBC Look North (North East/ Cumbria) or have recorded ITV News Tyne Tees, which these North Northumbrian viewers can then watch. With Scotland becoming an independent country in its own right all that changes, since ITV Border (Scotland) will no longer exist: Scottish Television (STV) East Scotland news centred on Edinburgh will (likely) be extended to the Selkirk transmitter in the Scottish Borders but it won’t cover northern Northumberland in output and coverage of the Scottish Borders and Lothian will be much- diluted by coverage of Edinburgh, Stirling, the Fife area. What’s more, it is likely that the Nationalist Scottish Government will have the Muxes and transmission frequencies changed so that any English aerials and televisions struggle to pick up the signal. North Northumbrians may well have to buy Scottish televisions (at considerable cost) to pick up news about what is happening over the Scottish Border!

For northern Northumbrian viewers, if and when Scotland becomes Independent the only real leverage with which to get more local news-coverage out of BBC Look North (North East/ Cumbria) or ITV News Tyne Tees will be two local Northumberland- based (currently You tube) Television stations, for which the technology should soon exist to get it on your television (by DVD if not!). They are NorthumberlandTV (website here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRjaNG8hxEey9jHfGPaSuVg) and for those in Northumberland’s Tyne Valley, HexhamTV (website here: https://hexhamtv.com/). One hopes that by the time Scotland declares full Independence from the United Kingdom at least one of these Northumberland Television “channels” will have progressed to something providing daily local news- and watchable on a television!

Thus, North Northumbrians will then still be able to write to ITV Tyne Tees and BBC North East Cumbria’s News Programmers to put pressure on them to provide more local news-coverage for Northumberland- and to also provide some overlap coverage into southern Scotland- perhaps from “Our Contact in Edinburgh” (this could be a news-feature): Easy cross-Border communication will likely no longer be possible so the North East’s Regional News Producers would likely rely on covert communication from someone living in a small flat in Edinburgh or Selkirk to provide Scottish Borders’ news: Programmers will thus need much more persuading than the great amount they would need now to provide any overlap cross- Border southern Scotland news-coverage!!! But the home-grown Northumberland- based Television news (if either the two mentioned above become so) then still provides a means of threatening to abandon BBC Look North or ITV Tyne Tees for a more local service, if they dont up their game.

But the truth is that, were Scotland to become independent with Border Police stationed at Carter Bar or just north of Berwick-upon-Tweed, getting news coverage from across the Scottish Border will as likely be even more elusive: If ITV Tyne Tees and BBC Look North refuse to run the gauntlet of having a “Necessary Spy” to report on happenings just across the Scottish Border, outfits such as HexhamTV and NorthumberlandTV are even less likely to have the resources to pay/ encourage someone to risk prosecution in Scotland to provide coverage of happenings just across the Scottish Border! So, for viewers of Regional and Local Television in Northumberland only a full- on one-two punch of threatening to watch a local Northumberland Television station- plus going to the length of getting a Scottish television to pick up southern Scotland news- may persuade either ITV Tyne Tees or BBC North East/Cumbria News Programmers that they need to pay someone good money to provide an item of Scottish Borders’ news as well as to cover locations “North of Tyne” much better so as not to lose potentially over 100,000 of their existing viewers!

In conclusion, for communities along the Scottish Border in north and north-west Northumberland, Scotland becoming independent will sever and damage cross-Border ties that have existed for hundreds of years in other ways: People who live in places like Duns and Eyemouth, over the Border into Scotland will not be able to shop or visit friends and family in Berwick-upon-Tweed. People who live in places like Otterburn, Norham or Wooler will likewise not be able to hop over into the Scottish Borders to visit friends, family members or have a day out in the Scottish Borders like they have done in the past.

For all these reasons, the author of this Website is against Scottish Nationalism leading to them breaking away from the United Kingdom: That’s because it will not just impact on Scotland but on places just south of the Scottish Border too- and if another Referendum on Scottish Independence happens in the next couple of years this Website will, for sure, make a resounding case for Scotland staying part of the United Kingdom on the basis that it will lead to a Hard Border cutting like a knife through and between communities along the Scottish Border: That will really hurt communities in Northumberland and northern Cumbria as well as those on the Scottish side of the Scottish Border.

15th September 2020: A New Site to focus on Regional Television coverage for the northern North East of England

Dear Readers

I already have a website that draws attention to the deficiencies in Regional Television for viewers of BBC North West Tonight and ITV Granada Reports who live in South Cumbria and northern Lancashire who do not get coverage of the northern half of North West England (i.e. Cumbria). This can be found at https://northwestisnorthwest.org/: Viewers in northern Lancashire and much of South Cumbria live just a bit too far south to receive an excellent signal from ITV Border (which covers Cumbria extremely well) and thus they have a choice between BBC North West Tonight or ITV Granada Reports, both of which will often not even mention Cumbria for a week, and they will often fail to cover anything north of Preston in their respective evening bulletins. Moreover, these programmes never cover even serious matters in northern Cumbria for the benefit of their viewers in the south of Cumbria: Thus not all of North West England is covered in Regional News programmes that say they cover North West England and the Isle of Man. I have therefore set up a Website which I am making the focal point for a Campaign to get the BBC and ITV in the North West to provide better local (and all- round) coverage for (potentially one million) viewers who live in a more northerly part of North West England who nevertheless suffer a poor North West Regional news-service.

However, this new Website is dedicated to viewers who live across the North Pennines and who also live in a rural county that extends well to the north of the urban areas of North East England- namely Northumberland. Since northernmost Northumberland was transferred from ITV Border to the ITV Tyne-Tees Region all of Northumberland now has a choice between ITV Tyne Tees or BBC Look North (the North East/ Cumbria version). Both these North East based Regional News services cover Northumberland poorly- one item out of ten news- items will be about rural North, West and Central Northumberland on a good night and there will be nothing north of Tyneside on a poor night. For the good folk of Berwick-upon-Tweed it means that “The News Where You Are”, as the BBC main news-presenter likes to say is sixty or more miles away (and often 100 or more miles away if its something about Middlesbrough, North Yorkshire- or West Cumbria). This is not acceptable for a Regional News- service that purports to serve everyone in North East England.

Rural northern Northumbrians also have strong links with communities across the Border into Scotland- particularly the Scottish Borders: The fact that Berwick Rangers is part of the Scottish Lowland Football League (and were part of the Scottish Professional Football League until last year) is one example of the cross- border ties. Edinburgh is less than an hour away from Berwick-upon-Tweed by train. However, this is not at all recognised by ITV Tyne Tees (the link-up with ITV Border has now been severed, which is actually good for folk living in northern Cumbria and southern Scotland who now get much more localised coverage) and not at all by BBC North East/ Cumbria programmers: Neither of the North-East based Regional News services provide any overlap coverage northwards into the Scottish Borders- which they should so that folk living at the northern margins of the transmission area receive more all-round coverage. This is therefore something that will be covered in posts on this Website and which will feature in the campaign to get Regional Television improved for viewers in Northumberland, so that they not only get more localised news- coverage of their communities but also a better perception of all-round local coverage too.

BBC Look North (North East and Cumbria) must indeed (as the name of the Regional News- programme suggests) Look North- to the often- neglected large rural hinterlands of Northumberland and the Scottish Borders: Hence the name of the Website (https://looknorthmustlooknorth.org/).